5 Best Rubber Mallet in the Market: Reviewed & Rated

best rubber mallet

A rubber mallet is a key tool for projects that require a softer touch. With its ability to deliver force without damaging surfaces, the rubber mallet is ideal for tasks that need careful handling. From home repairs to crafting, knowing the right rubber mallet can make all the difference. In this article, I'm excited to share my insights on the best rubber mallet choices available in 2024. If you're looking for a reliable rubber mallet to add to your toolkit, follow along as I review the top picks that have earned high marks across the board.

What Is A Rubber Mallet?

A rubber mallet is a type of hammer with a head made of rubber instead of metal or wood. The softer material of the rubber hammer makes it perfect for tasks where you need a good thump without leaving a mark. This tool is especially handy when you're working with materials that can easily dent, like wood, leather, or certain metals.

One of the main reasons you will prefer a rubber mallet hammer over other types of hammers is to avoid damage. Because of its rubber head, it delivers a softer blow. This is ideal for tasks like fitting parts together in a woodworking project, tapping tiles into place without cracking them, or even popping out a dent in your car's bodywork. Essentially, anywhere you need a bit of force without the harsh impact, a rubber hammer is your go-to tool.

Using a rubber mallet also comes with the advantage of noise reduction. Unlike the sharp clank of a metal hammer, a rubber mallet’s thud is much quieter, making it a preferred choice in noise-sensitive environments or when working late at night in a garage close to sleeping quarters.

What Is A Rubber Mallet Used For?

  • Rubber mallet hammer is often used in woodworking and carpentry. It helps in assembling or dismantling furniture without causing damage, making it a preferred choice for builders and DIY enthusiasts.
  • Installing tiles is another common rubber mallet use. The soft head of a rubber mallet hammer allows you to tap tiles into place without cracking them, ensuring a smooth installation process.
  • When you need to fit parts together in automotive or boat repair, a rubber mallet proves useful. It provides the necessary force without leaving marks, which is important for maintaining a pristine finish.
  • Leatherworking also benefits from the gentle touch of a rubber mallet. It's used to stamp or shape leather without cutting or bruising the material, allowing for precision work.
  • In musical instrument assembly, particularly with drums, a rubber mallet is vital. It allows musicians or manufacturers to adjust components gently, ensuring everything fits perfectly without harm.


Key Features to Consider When Buying a Rubber Mallet

When you're in the market for a rubber mallet hammer, it's not just about picking the first one you see. Like choosing the right tool for any job, there are specific features you should consider to make sure you get the best rubber mallet for your needs. Let's break these down:

Head Material

The business end of a rubber mallet is, of course, the head. But not all rubber is the same. Some are softer, great for delicate work where you can't afford to leave a mark. Others are harder, offering more durability for those tougher jobs. The type of rubber impacts how long the mallet hammer will last and what you can do with it. Think about the rubber mallet uses to guide you in choosing the right kind of rubber head.

Handle Material

The handle is what you'll be holding onto, so it plays an important role. They can be made from wood, fiberglass, or metal, each with its own set of pros and cons. Wood handles absorb some of the vibrations, making them more comfortable for long periods of use. Fiberglass handles are lightweight and extremely durable, while metal handles are the toughest of them all. Your choice should balance comfort, durability, and how much weight you're comfortable handling.

Weight and Size

Rubber mallets come in a variety of weights and sizes. A heavier mallet hammer packs more punch but can tire you out quicker, while a lighter one is easier to handle but might not deliver the force you need for some tasks. The size of the head should also match the precision required for your work. Bigger isn't always better; sometimes a smaller, more manageable size is what you need for the job at hand.


You'll find rubber mallets with either one face or two (double-faced). A double-faced rubber mallet hammer can be handy because it gives you two surfaces to work with, possibly of different hardnesses. A single-faced rubber mallet might be all you need for specific tasks, especially if it's designed for a particular purpose. Consider what you'll be using it for most often to decide which design suits your needs best.

5 Best Rubber Mallets: In-Depth Review

Choosing the right rubber mallet can significantly enhance the effectiveness and quality of your projects. Below, I explore the five best rubber mallets on the market, highlighting their standout features and practical benefits to help you make an informed purchasing decision.

STANLEY Rubber Mallet

The STANLEY Rubber Mallet is praised for its high-quality construction and effective design. Users appreciate its sturdy build and the smooth finish of the handle, which enhances grip while preventing splinters. While it receives high marks for its practicality and performance, some users have expressed mixed feelings about its overall appearance and long-term durability.

Minimized Surface Damage: The rubber head is designed to prevent marring and damage to surfaces.
Durable Construction: Features a tough rubber head that is securely molded to a wooden handle.
Comfortable Grip: The wood handle ensures a comfortable hold, reducing fatigue during extended use.

Head Material: Rubber Handle Material: Wood Weight: ‎16 oz Size: 14-inch long

Estwing Rubber Mallet

The Estwing Rubber Mallet stands out with its innovative TRIPLE WEDGE CONSTRUCTION that securely attaches the hammer head to its hickory handle, designed to withstand rigorous use. Tailored for professionals like framers, roofers, and carpenters, as well as serious DIY enthusiasts, it promises reliability and efficiency. The mallet is also celebrated for its versatility, proving invaluable in tasks ranging from sheet metal forming to furniture assembly and camping.

Optimized Handle Design: The genuine hickory handle offers a lightweight feel tailored to fit the user’s grip, ensuring enhanced comfort and control.
Dual Hardness: Features a dual-hardness head with one soft and one hard side for different types of impacts.
Versatile Use: Ideal for a variety of applications, including upholstery, automotive work, and tile setting.

Head Material: Rubber, one soft and one hard Handle Material: ‎Hickory Wood Weight: 12 oz Size: ‎14-inch long

Coleman Rubber Mallet

The Coleman Rubber Mallet is designed with campers in mind, featuring a high-impact, double-sided rubber head ideal for securing plastic or steel tent pegs into hard ground. This mallet is appreciated for its durability and ease of use, making setting up camp a breeze. Additionally, the built-in end hook for pulling out tent stakes adds functionality, making it a versatile and important tool for any camping trip.

High-Impact Rubber Head: Ensures durability and effectiveness when hammering tent stakes.
Built-In Tent Peg Remover: Includes a convenient hook for quick removal of stakes, enhancing its utility.
Easy Handling: The design focuses on ease of use, especially in outdoor and camping environments.

Head Material: ‎Rubber Handle Material: ‎Wood Weight: 16 oz Size: 14-inch long

Edward Tools Rubber Mallet Hammer

The Edward Tools Rubber Mallet Hammer is a robust tool, perfect for a variety of applications where a soft, non-damaging blow is necessary. This mallet's durable rubber head ensures that it can deliver gentle strikes without harming the surface, making it ideal for flooring, woodworking, and even jewelry work. Its extra-strength fiberglass handle, equipped with shock absorption, and an ergonomic non-slip rubber grip make it a favorite for professionals and DIYers alike for its comfort and efficiency during use.

Durable Rubber Head: Engineered for soft blows that prevent damage to work surfaces.
Shock Absorbing Handle: The fiberglass handle with shock absorption minimizes vibration, enhancing comfort.
Ergonomic Grip: Features a non-slip rubber grip that ensures steady handling and increased control.

Head Material: ‎Rubber Handle Material: ‎Fiberglass Weight: 16 oz Size: ‎13-inch long

Titan Rubber Mallet

The Titan Rubber Mallet is highly regarded for its robust design and practicality across various applications, including fabrication, construction, and automotive work. This mallet features a non-marking, double-faced solid rubber head that's perfect for use on softer surfaces where avoiding damage is key. Customers praise its build quality and performance, noting the mallet's durability and how well it handles demanding tasks. The strong, fiberglass handle with its textured, cushioned grip ensures comfort and control, significantly reducing shocks and vibrations during use.

Non-Marking Rubber Head: Double-faced and solid, ideal for delicate surfaces without leaving marks.
Shock Absorbing Handle: The fiberglass handle is designed to absorb shocks, making prolonged use more comfortable.
Textured Grip: A cushioned, non-slip grip enhances handling and prevents the mallet from slipping during use.

Head Material: ‎Rubber Handle Material: Fiberglass Weight: 32 oz Size: 14.8-inch long


Rubber Mallet Maintenance Tips

To ensure your rubber mallet hammer remains in top condition and continues to perform at its best, proper maintenance is key. These tips are designed to extend the lifespan of your rubber mallet, preserving its effectiveness for all your projects.

  • Store Properly: Keep your rubber mallet hammer in a cool, dry place to prevent the rubber from becoming brittle and cracking.
  • Clean Regularly: After each use, wipe down your rubber hammer to remove debris and moisture, which can degrade the material over time.
  • Inspect for Damage: Regularly check both the rubber head and handle for any signs of wear or damage to ensure safety and efficiency.
  • Avoid Sunlight: Prolonged exposure to direct sunlight can deteriorate the rubber on your rubber hammer, so store it away from harsh UV rays.
  • Use Appropriately: To maintain the integrity of your rubber mallet use, only use it for appropriate tasks to avoid unnecessary damage.

Following these maintenance tips will help keep your best rubber mallet in excellent condition, ready for whatever task comes next.

Rubber Mallet FAQs

When would you use a rubber mallet instead of a hammer?

A rubber mallet is used instead of a hammer when you need to apply force without damaging the surface. It's ideal for tasks like assembling furniture or setting tiles where a softer touch is necessary.

What can you use as a substitute for a rubber mallet?

If you don't have a rubber mallet, a wooden or plastic mallet can be used as a substitute. These materials also provide a softer impact than metal hammers, though they might not be as effective for all tasks that a rubber mallet would excel in.

What is the difference between rubber mallet and wood mallet?

The main difference between a rubber mallet and a wood mallet is the material of the head. Rubber mallets provide a softer impact and reduce damage to surfaces, whereas wood mallets can deliver a firmer strike and are typically used for woodworking and chiseling.

What is the best weight for a rubber mallet?

The best weight for a rubber mallet typically ranges from 12 to 32 ounces, depending on the specific tasks it's used for. Lighter mallets are suitable for delicate tasks like leatherwork, while heavier ones are better for more robust applications like construction.

What is the difference between black and white rubber mallet?

The difference between black and white rubber mallets usually lies in the hardness and non-marking properties of the rubber. Black rubber mallets are generally harder and more durable, whereas white rubber mallets are softer and less likely to leave marks on surfaces.

Can you use a rubber mallet for chiseling?

Yes, you can use a rubber hammer for chiseling when working with soft materials or when precision is needed without damaging the chisel handle or workpiece.

Can you use a rubber mallet for leatherwork?

Yes, a rubber hammer is ideal for leatherwork, as it helps in stamping, carving, and shaping leather without cutting or marking the surface.

TRADESAFE is a leading provider of industrial safety products, featuring Lockout Tagout (LOTO) devices, workplace signs, and other supplies aimed at enhancing workplace safety and exceeding compliance with regulations.

The material provided in this article is for general information purposes only. It is not intended to replace professional/legal advice or substitute government regulations, industry standards, or other requirements specific to any business/activity. While we made sure to provide accurate and reliable information, we make no representation that the details or sources are up-to-date, complete or remain available. Readers should consult with an industrial safety expert, qualified professional, or attorney for any specific concerns and questions.


Shop Tradesafe Products

Author: Herbert Post

Born in the Philadelphia area and raised in Houston by a family who was predominately employed in heavy manufacturing. Herb took a liking to factory processes and later safety compliance where he has spent the last 13 years facilitating best practices and teaching updated regulations. He is married with two children and a St Bernard named Jose. Herb is a self-described compliance geek. When he isn’t studying safety reports and regulatory interpretations he enjoys racquetball and watching his favorite football team, the Dallas Cowboys.