During our recent toolbox talk on confined space safety, I realized that workers often associate confined space hazards with toxic gases and engulfment, while overlooking physical dangers that can be just as deadly. These hazards, such as unexpected equipment startup, shifting materials, and unstable structures, are often less obvious but are immediately dangerous to life and can lead to serious injuries or fatalities. In fact, physical hazards account for roughly 20% of all confined space-related fatalities.
In this article, we’ll take a closer look at confined space isolation, a key part of any confined space safety program that helps implement adequate control measures for hazardous energy, toxic gases, and unexpected material releases before entry.
Key Takeaways
-
Confined space isolation controls hazardous energy and materials to ensure safe employee entry, preventing exposure to harmful substances and risks.
-
Positive isolation involves methods like blinds, caps, or removing pipe sections to physically block hazardous materials or energy from entering a confined space.
-
Isolation of confined spaces should be customized based on a facility’s unique processes, energy types, and operational needs to ensure safety during entry and work.
-
Confined space isolation must address all permit space hazards, including hidden sources like gravity, residual energy, heat, and external dangers such as moving vehicles.
What Is Confined Space Isolation?
29 CFR 1910.146(b) defines isolation in confined space as the process of eliminating or controlling hazardous energy, materials, or substances before workers enter a permit-required confined space (PRCS). This is done using methods like blanking off pipes, disconnecting lines, double block and bleed, locking/tagging out energy sources, or blocking mechanical parts. The goal is to ensure no chemical, gas, electricity, or moving equipment can reach or affect workers inside the space.
For example, OSHA requires pipes and lines connected to a confined space to be physically blocked or disconnected (not just closed) to stop hazardous flow. Similarly, any mechanical or electrical equipment that could activate must be locked out and secured against movement, as outlined in OSHA’s Control of Hazardous Energy (Lockout/Tagout) standard (29 CFR 1910.147).
However, confined space isolation is more than just a compliance requirement—it is a critical safety measure that protects workers from deadly hazards. In fact, OSHA reports that the number of fatalities in confined spaces in the United States has ranged from 88 in 2012 to 166 in 2017. Without proper isolation, permit-required confined spaces can quickly turn into death traps, leading to asphyxiation, toxic exposure, fires, explosions, or crushing injuries.
What Are the Confined Space Isolation Requirements?
Under the permit space program outlined in OSHA 1910.146(d), employers are required to isolate PRCS for safe permit space entry operations. Several methods are used to achieve isolation in confined space work. Each method targets a particular permit space hazard, and often, multiple methods are combined for full protection. The primary isolation methods include:
Lockout Tagout of All Sources of Energy
Lockout tagout (LOTO) is the standard practice for isolating hazardous energies so that equipment cannot start up or release energy. It involves identifying all energy sources that could affect the space, such as electrical motors, pumps, fans, agitators, steam lines, pressurized air, or hydraulic systems. Then, energy sources are placed in a zero-energy state and secured with lockout devices and LOTO tags to prevent accidental re-energization.
Consider a large mixer or agitator inside a tank; the electrical disconnect switch for that mixer must be turned off and locked out using a push button lockout device before anyone enters the confined space. LOTO ensures that all forms of energy remain off. It is often used in combination with other methods—for instance, lockout a valve that is part of a double block & bleed setup, or lockout the breaker after shutting a pump feeding a tank. This method addresses hazards that are not just materials entering the space but also machinery movement or electrical shock.
Blanking or Blinding
This involves placing a solid barrier in a pipe, duct, or line to completely block flow. OSHA describes this as the “absolute closure of a pipe, line, or duct by the fastening of a solid plate that completely covers the bore and can withstand the maximum pressure with no leakage.”
In practice, this may be done with devices like spectacle blinds or skillet blinds, essentially metal discs inserted between pipe flanges, or by capping the line. Once a blind is installed, no gas or liquid can pass into the confined space. This method is commonly called positive isolation because it provides a physical, verifiable separation.
Before maintenance workers enter a process vessel in petroleum or chemical plants, technicians often insert blinds on inlet and outlet pipes to ensure that dangerous chemicals or steam cannot enter. Blanking or blinding is one of the most foolproof isolation methods, suitable for high-risk lines because even if a valve leaks or is accidentally opened upstream, the blind stops any flow.
Double Block and Bleed Systems
Double block and bleed is a method of isolating piping using two in-line valves shut in series, with a bleed valve between them. Both block valves are closed and secured with a gate valve lockout. Then, the small bleed valve in the section between them is opened to vent any residual fluid.
The purpose of the bleed is to relieve any pressure and to verify the seals: if either primary valve leaks, it will show up as flow out of the open bleed. This method is considered a high level of isolation—if one valve fails, the second still holds, and any leakage is safely released through the bleed rather than reaching the confined space. The double block and bleed system is widely used in oil and gas industries and chemical plants when inserting blinds is impractical.
However, some safety standards require a blank flange if the fluid is highly toxic or flammable, as even two well-maintained valves carry a small risk of leakage. In most maintenance scenarios, though, a properly executed double block and bleed—where valves are locked and the bleed valve is verified open—provides sufficient isolation to prevent any material from reaching workers inside the permit required confined space.
Line Disconnection (Misaligning or Removing Sections)
Physical line disconnection entails misaligning a pipe or removing a spool piece or section of line to create an air gap so that no continuous path exists for a substance to travel. In practice, this might mean unbolting a pipe segment or uncoupling a hose attached to the confined space and perhaps installing a blank flange on the open end. The result is similar to blanking, a permanent separation, but by taking apart the connection entirely. Any fluid that might accidentally be sent toward the space will simply spill out of the disconnected line segment rather than enter the space.
This approach provides a very high assurance of safety as the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) notes, “an effective method is to disconnect the confined space completely from the supply”.. Whenever lines are removed or misaligned, it’s important to secure the open ends to ensure no debris can fall in and to double-check that the right line has been disconnected.
Blocking or Disconnecting All Mechanical Linkages
Some permit required confined spaces contain mechanical parts that could move, rotate, or fall and injure entrants if not secured. Blocking or disconnecting mechanical linkages means physically preventing motion by separating the drive mechanism or inserting a block to immobilize it. This could involve removing drive belts or chains, inserting pins or chocks to lock a gear or shaft, or using a brace to hold back a counterweight.
From the previous example of a large mixer or agitator inside a tank, placing chocks, wooden blocks, or metal braces against the agitator blades or shaft prevents any unintended shifting. Since electrical lockout alone isn’t always enough, mechanical blocks help prevent motion caused by gravity, hydraulic drift, or residual energy. As always, any such blocks or disconnections should be noted on the confined space entry permit and verified.
In some industries, barriers or shields may also be used as a form of isolation to protect entrants from external physical hazards. For example, OSHA construction confined space rules (Subpart AA of 29 CFR 1926) mention using barriers to block contact with nearby equipment or live electrical parts. However, these are generally supplemental controls; confined space isolation requirements focus on eliminating hazardous energy and material exposure at the source.
Confined Space Isolation Best Practices
One of the most prevalent and hazardous mistakes in a required confined space program is the failure to follow established safety procedures. In fact, a study highlighted that in 31% of confined space fatalities, organizations had written procedures, yet none were followed during the incidents. This alarming statistic highlights the need for more than just policies on paper—effective training, enforcement, and a strong safety culture are essential to preventing these tragedies.
Over the years, safety experts have developed best practices to ensure effective isolation. These go hand-in-hand with regulatory requirements but often provide additional assurance above the minimum:
-
-
Use Positive Isolation Whenever Feasible: Positive isolation refers to methods that physically separate the space from hazards such as blinds, caps, or removed pipe sections. This is especially recommended if the hazard is toxic, flammable, or high-pressure.
-
Plan and Document All Isolation Points: A thorough isolation plan should be prepared as part of the confined space entry permit system, listing every energy source and line that needs isolation and the method used for each.
-
Lockout Tagout All Applicable Controls: Even when other methods are used, lock valves in the closed position and lock switches in OFF. Use multi-lock hasps if multiple workers are involved so that each can apply their lock.
-
Verify Isolations: After isolating, try to introduce the hazard in a controlled way to see if it’s truly blocked. This step catches any oversight before anyone enters.
-
Address All Types Of Hazards: This includes less obvious energy sources, like gravity (could something fall or flow downhill into the space?), stored energy in springs or hydraulic accumulators, thermal energy (steam lines that could conduct heat), or even external vehicles (lockout might include barricading a crane that swings overhead).
-
Communicate and Train on Isolation Procedures: All employees involved need to know what isolations are in place and why. It’s good practice for the entry team to review the isolation plan in a toolbox talk before the job.
-
Employers should also conduct hazard assessments tailored to their specific processes, energy sources, and operational constraints to determine the most effective permit required confined space isolation method. For example, a food processing plant's confined space hazards are vastly different from a municipal sewer system. Blindly applying generic isolation techniques can create more risks than it prevents.
Confined Space Isolation FAQs
What is positive isolation in confined space?
Positive isolation means completely blocking hazardous energy or substances from entering a confined space by using methods like blanking and blinding, double block and bleed, or physically disconnecting pipelines rather than relying on closed valves alone.
What happens if a confined space is not properly isolated?
Failure to properly isolate a confined space can lead to toxic gas exposure, engulfment, explosions, electrocution, or mechanical entrapment, putting workers at severe risk of injury or death.
How many confined space deaths happen each year?
According to the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), the annual figures for fatalities in confined spaces range from a low of 88 in 2012 to a high of 166 in 2017 in the United States. These fatalities are often caused by falls and engulfment in other collapsing materials.
What are OSHA’s confined space isolation requirements?
OSHA’s 29 CFR 1910.146 (Permit-Required Confined Spaces) and 1910.147 (Lockout/Tagout) mandate that employers fully isolate hazardous energy and substances before entry using LOTO, pipeline disconnection, or physical barriers.
What are the most effective isolation methods for confined spaces?
The most effective confined space isolation methods include Lockout/Tagout (LOTO), blanking and blinding, double block and bleed, pipeline disconnection, and mechanical blocking of moving parts, ensuring that no hazardous energy or material can reach workers inside the space.