OSHA’s Three Lines of Defense: Engineering Controls, Administrative Controls, and PPE

Industrial workers looking at a clipboard

OSHA’s Three Lines of Defense

The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) has established a framework known as the Three Lines of Defense to ensure that workers are protected from hazards in the workplace. The Three Lines of Defense is a systematic approach to hazard control that consists of three distinct layers of protection: engineering controls, administrative controls, and personal protective equipment (PPE).

Engineering controls are the first line of defense. The implementation of engineering controls is essential in minimizing the risks that workers face in their daily tasks. Proper maintenance and evaluation of these controls are also crucial in preventing injuries, illnesses, and fatalities in the workplace. Administrative controls, the second line of defense, involve policies, procedures, and training that aim to minimize exposure to workplace hazards. PPE, the third line of defense, involves the use of equipment to protect workers from exposure to hazards.

This article aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of OSHA's Three Lines of Defense and emphasize its critical role in protecting workers from workplace hazards.

Engineering Controls

Engineering controls are physical or mechanical means of hazard control that are designed to eliminate or minimize exposure to workplace hazards and is considered the most effective among the three lines of defense.

There are various types of engineering controls, including barriers, ventilation systems, machine guards, and enclosures. Barriers are used to physically separate workers from hazards, while ventilation systems remove hazardous substances from the air. Machine guards and enclosures are used to protect workers from moving parts and hazardous equipment.

Some important points to consider regarding engineering controls:

  • Advantages and limitations of engineering controls: The advantages of engineering controls include their effectiveness in controlling hazards and their ability to provide long-term protection for workers. However, engineering controls may be costly to implement and may require ongoing maintenance to ensure their continued effectiveness.
  • Importance of proper implementation and maintenance: Proper implementation and maintenance of engineering controls are crucial to their effectiveness in reducing hazards. Employers must ensure that engineering controls are properly installed, used, and maintained to provide maximum protection for workers.

Administrative Controls

Administrative controls help reduce accidents and injuries in the workplace through the implementation of employee training, safety policies, and procedures. This type of control is the second line of defense and is used when engineering controls are not feasible or insufficient.

Examples of administrative controls include job rotation, training, hazard communication, and implementing safe work practices. Job rotation involves rotating workers between different tasks to minimize their exposure to hazards. Hazard communication involves providing workers with information about hazards in the workplace.

Some important points to consider regarding administrative controls:

  • Advantages and limitations of administrative controls: The advantages of administrative controls include their flexibility and relatively low cost compared to engineering controls. However, administrative controls are less effective at controlling hazards than engineering controls and may rely on worker compliance to be effective.
  • Importance of proper implementation and enforcement: Proper implementation and enforcement of administrative controls are crucial to their effectiveness in reducing hazards. Employers must ensure that administrative controls are properly communicated, implemented, and enforced to provide maximum protection for workers.

Personal Protective Equipment (PPE)

Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) is the last line of defense in the Three Lines of Defense framework established by OSHA to protect workers from workplace hazards.

different types of ppe

PPE includes equipment such as gloves, respirators, hard hats, and safety glasses that workers use to protect themselves from hazards such as chemical exposure, loud noises, and head injuries. PPE is only used when engineering and administrative controls are not feasible or insufficient.

Some important points to consider regarding PPE:

  • Advantages and limitations of PPE: The advantages of PPE include their relatively low cost and ease of use. However, PPE is less effective than engineering and administrative controls at controlling hazards, and its effectiveness depends on proper selection, use, and maintenance.
  • Importance of proper selection, use, and maintenance: Proper selection, use, and maintenance of PPE are crucial to its effectiveness in protecting workers. Employers must ensure that workers are properly trained on the selection and use of PPE, and that the equipment is regularly inspected, maintained, and replaced as needed.

How the Three Lines of Defense Work Together

OSHA's Three Lines of Defense, consisting of engineering controls, administrative controls, and personal protective equipment (PPE), work together to provide a comprehensive approach to hazard control. All three types of controls must be used in conjunction with each other for an effective hazard control program. When implemented properly, engineering controls can eliminate or reduce the hazard at the source, while administrative controls and PPE can provide additional layers of protection.

Successful implementation of the Three Lines of Defense can be seen in various industries, such as the use of engineering controls to reduce noise levels in manufacturing plants, administrative controls to improve safety practices in construction sites, and the use of PPE to protect healthcare workers from infectious diseases.

Implementation Strategies

Implementing OSHA's three lines of defense can be challenging, but there are several steps that can be taken to ensure a successful implementation:

Steps to Implement Engineering Controls

  • Identify hazards in the workplace that can be controlled by engineering solutions
  • Choose the most effective engineering control options
  • Design, install, and maintain the engineering controls
  • Train employees on how to use and maintain the engineering controls

Steps to Implement Administrative Controls

  • Identify the hazards that cannot be controlled by engineering solutions
  • Develop and implement administrative policies and procedures to minimize the hazards
  • Train employees on the administrative controls and ensure their compliance
  • Monitor the effectiveness of the administrative controls and make necessary changes

Steps to Select and Use PPE

Identify the hazards that cannot be controlled by engineering or administrative controls

  • Select appropriate PPE that provides adequate protection for the hazards
  • Train employees on how to properly use and maintain the PPE
  • Ensure that employees are using PPE correctly and that it is being properly maintained
Proper implementation of OSHA's three lines of defense requires a proactive approach and a commitment to maintaining a safe and healthy workplace. By following these strategies, employers can create a positive and healthy work environment, ensure workers’ safety and avoid potential fines and penalties for noncompliance.

The material provided in this article is for general information purposes only. It is not intended to replace professional/legal advice or substitute government regulations, industry standards, or other requirements specific to any business/activity. While we made sure to provide accurate and reliable information, we make no representation that the details or sources are up-to-date, complete or remain available. Readers should consult with an industrial safety expert, qualified professional, or attorney for any specific concerns and questions.

ENSURE SAFETY WITH PREMIUM SOLUTIONS

Shop Tradesafe Products

Author: Herbert Post

Born in the Philadelphia area and raised in Houston by a family who was predominately employed in heavy manufacturing. Herb took a liking to factory processes and later safety compliance where he has spent the last 13 years facilitating best practices and teaching updated regulations. He is married with two children and a St Bernard named Jose. Herb is a self-described compliance geek. When he isn’t studying safety reports and regulatory interpretations he enjoys racquetball and watching his favorite football team, the Dallas Cowboys.